Sunday 25 January 2015

American Studies Blog 2

Post and discuss any diary or journal of the settlement of the Western USA.

Reminiscences of a Trip Across the Plains in '45
By Mrs. Burnett (nee Lucy Jane Hall)
America is still one of the most immigrated places of today and this hasn’t changed since its discovery. As Thomas Paine states in: Common Sense, America offered a land in which anyone could “begin the world again.” (1776). This made millions of people from all over the world want to immigrate to become a part of this new way of life. America, as we know, was a land of cultural diversity, political freedom, had an abundance of space and was full of natural resources. American was viewed as, “the last, best hope of mankind”, as President Abraham Lincoln; spoke in this message to the Congress in 1862. Mrs Lucy Burnett moved westwards across the Plains to Oregon in 1845 and I will look to explore and discuss her journey. Oregon was one of the last places to be settled in, as it was part of the Pacific Coastal Range, on the Western Coast. It would have been one of the last voyages as it was only a few years after, when the railroads would have been finished in 1869.




Image 1 & 2: Henry J. Warre “Sketches in North America and the Oregon Territory” (1848)

The website I took my source from is a tourist site for Oregon. It features a vast amount of the State’s history. The section, which presents Mrs Lucy Burnett’s account, also has a list of other biographies from at the time of “early Oregon Pioneers”. The website looks to share these stories, but further ideally wants readers to add to their current material.

Mrs Lucy Burnett states her story rather factually, with little to no emotion and is very to the point throughout. She writes that her father was the captain of the train, implicating that she comes from a wealthy family and continues that her and about “thirty wagons and about fifty men” were making their journey across the Plains to Oregon, “The Dalles” specifically. Initially she creates an image of normality as she describes a wedding within their travelling group and that they “dance[d] on the grass under the stars.” This further implicates that certain members on this voyage would have been wealthy to under go this journey in a particular luxury.
Interestingly Mrs Burnett, in comparison to the rest of her account, goes into particular detail of an attack by the Indians early into their trip. This could be due to it being one of her first encounters with  Indians. The captain offers peace by showing a “white flag” and the journey continues.
At this point, the group decide to change direction and listen to a member of the group called,Stephen Meek, who stated he knew a “much shorter route” which was further from the “danger [of] the Indians”. A few weeks after following Mr Meek’s directions, he announces that he is lost, and intriguingly Mrs Burnett says that the group were “alarmed, but not dismayed.” I personally find this particularly fascinating as to many, this new land would have seemed easy once arriving, however in reality the settlement and the expansion westwards for many would have been difficult. Mrs Burnett seems to not be under any allusion of this trip being easy.
She reinforces the idea of America as a “wilderness” and that the West held challenges of an alien environment by writing, “there was neither grass nor water”.
Mrs Burnett remembers the words from Mr Meek “we are saved, we are saved! Thank God … for now I know the way.” This would have been a momentous occasion of relief as the group could continue their route in the right direction. “Men, women and children were laughing and crying in turn.” Mrs Burnett writes that many people were sick and some had even died from the journey.
Mr Meek and his wife escaped during one evening and left the group to navigate for themselves. They eventually came across “a white man and two Indians” who helped them arrive in “The Dalles”.

What I found most fascinating with this account is Mrs Hall’s perception of the Indians. With her fist encounter with them, she describes in detail the Indians with, “they had fine horses. The men were nude and painted.” This links to the watercolour drawing of an American “Indian in Body Paint” by John White 1585-1586, where his interpretation is one of the most famous representations of an Indian.



Image: John White “Indian in Body Paint” 1585-86
Source from: http://guity-novin.blogspot.co.uk/2012/01/chapter-51-art-of-of-body-painting.html

Also, Mrs Burnett describes the Indians as non-violent, when they are confronted by the Captain with a white flag, they ran away “as fast as their horses could go.” Furthermore, it was the Indians who helped them at the end of their journey, “they made us understand that a man and a woman crossed the river a short time before.” This portrays a different relationship that the whites had with the Indians. The idea of “manifest destiny” being a disaster for Indians, however from the interpretation from Mrs Burnett’s account, they seem to be working together peacefully. Mrs Burnett also finished her account by thanking the people that saved her as they “would have perished” having not been found.


Mrs Lucy Burnett’s account is fascinating as it’s from a third person account. She appears rather detached from her story, almost as if it’s a time she doesn’t want to relive her journey. Many other American’s would have experienced difficult settlement like Mrs Burnett, and some would have experienced much worse. Mrs Burnett reinforces that the settlement within the West wasn’t as easy as many dreamed it would be.

No comments:

Post a Comment